Review: Dexter: Resurrection, "Young Blood" | Season 2, Episode 4
The Jawsplitter brings us the best of both Dexter worlds, old and new
I was pretty clear in my assessment of this season right out of the gate—things are cooking. The show has been leaning into its new-and-improved elements with gusto, delivering wry humor and clever plotting in equal measure. But something unexpected happened this week: Old Dexter crept back into the mix. The pacing, the steady thematic intermingling of the kill-of-the-week and his personal life, the unexpected shakeup in characters—all of it felt like a great Dexter episode from the early years. All the things that make Resurrection great were present as well, but fused to the chassis of a classic installment. In other words: I pity anyone who couldn't be convinced to tune back in after the first series petered out, because this show is justifying its existence and then some; I'd put this episode up against just about any prototypical example of the series as it should be. Not "best," necessarily, but certainly most representative.
Setting us up to expect the Jawsplitter and then giving his son instead was a tweak worthy of the 5BK. (Yes, I see that on the show, in canon, the shorthand for Dan Stevens' killer is FBK. While I maintain this is a stupider acronym, I will accede to the inevitability of fate, and change mine to match going forward.) John Thomas, Jr. (played to irritating-but-ace perfection by Jack Dylan Grazer) shows up full of nervous excitement and obnoxious bravado, and the question of whether or not he'll end up on Dexter's kill table fuels a good amount of the episode's drama. It feels apropos that he ends up being both sympathetic victim and murderous monster, worthy of death under the code but still so damaged that you can't help feeling a little sympathy. Despite all the times we root for a "fun" kill, that grey zone between justice and compulsion, right and wrong, is where the sharpest episodes of Dexter have always lived. Moral ambiguity, when done right (which often wasn't the case in later years), has driven the most compelling storylines, and wavering on the question of John Jr.'s guilt was a stellar example.
From the first moments that Charley and Dexter encounter him, forcing the young man to his knees and extracting the truth about his parentage, John Jr. blew through this episode like a hurricane, unsettling our protagonists and drawing eerie parallels with Harrison. (I should've known the teleplay—credited to Katrina Mathewson and Tanner Bean—would almost instantly make all subtext screamingly loud text; again, the same as Dexter of old.) But when such comparisons are staring you in the face that hard, it would have been weird not to address it. "My son shot me because he didn't want to be like me," Dex tells John when the latter is securely bound on his table, making clear why the budding serial killer has to go. Where Harrison zigged, John Jr. zagged, embracing everything Dexter initially thought he wanted for his son. His guileless, earnest demeanor is sort of endearing, right until it pivots to being just as psychotic and bloodthirsty as his dad.