Review: Survivor, "Wilder than a Cat in the Bathtub" | Season 51, Episode 9
I hope you're hungry—for nothing but a fried chicken reward
I know I said that Ben and I were alternating with Survivor this season, but it ended up being a little more chaotic thanks to some scheduling necessities. This means that Ben’s gotten to handle a lot of the post-merge game, including last week’s double-elimination, and thus I’m coming in with…okay, I was going to suggest I had a lot to say, but I know that's not true.
As we face the reality of a full season of two-hour episodes in the spring—I swear if we don’t get weekly reward challenges I’m going to lose my mind—it’s a time to reflect on how we think about “filler” in a Survivor season. There was a lot of excitement in last week’s episode, and you can’t claim it wasn’t a momentous tribal council, but here’s the thing: its primary function in the game is speeding up the removal of castaways. They need to get rid of players in multiples when they’re doing 26-day seasons, and so episodes like that one are very exciting in the moment and then when you see the aftermath you realize that it hasn’t made the game better in any way. It’s just allowed the season to move on procedurally to ten players remaining instead of twelve.
This makes it seem silly that we’re spending time each week reflecting on each episode, but how the show moves procedurally is variable, and there’s sometimes interpersonal drama that is worth considering otherwise. But I don’t know if I believe there's anything interesting happening this time around. In the aftermath of last week’s removal of Kristin and Kolby, I was mostly annoyed that everyone seemed to think that there were “big moves” at that tribal. Cristian playing his shot-in-the-dark is not a “move”: it’s just burning something that the majority of players won’t use anyway, and landing on safe was pure luck. And when everyone is convinced that Jelly is now the biggest threat, this is because she…found an immunity idol and used it in the single most logical situation where it protected both her and an ally?