Review: Elsbeth, “Lean Girls” | Season 4, Episode 6 / Cupertino, "Judith and Michael" | Season 1, Episode 8
Being a part of something special makes you special, right?
“Pilates studios can be like high school.”
The long arc of TV history is ever-present in modern-day shows. We know Elsbeth is, by its very nature, inspired by Columbo. I was surprised by how specific the reference felt this time around. One of the key details within the murder in "Lean Girls" is reminiscent of an early episode of Columbo called “Death Lends a Hand.” There, a gruff private investigator kills the wife of one of his rich clients in a fit of murderous passion, striking her so hard that she lands on a sharp table and dies as a result. In the process of getting rid of her body, he believes one of her contact lens fell out and he attempts as best he can to locate and remove this miniature item. The episode concludes with the investigator breaking into the car he used to dump the body, under the false belief that the contact lens is located there. He’s only stopped by Columbo, who arrests him and points out that he bluffed in convincing the anxiety-ridden investigator that he hadn’t cleaned up thoroughly.
In “Lean Girls,” Pilates instructor Darcy Miles (Lea Michele) kills Norma (Chloe Troast), a talented client who she fears is going to open up a rival studio and poach Darcy’s students. During a mostly off-screen scuffle, Darcy’s beaded necklace splits apart and all of the beads fly across an otherwise spotless studio. Darcy is depicted as a hyper-fastidious cleaner, so she definitely found all of the beads in the process of erasing any trace of her presence at Norma’s studio. …Or did she? I clocked pretty quickly (thanks to the insert shot of the necklace splitting apart) that the beads would come into play quite soon. I wasn’t quite expecting Elsbeth to pull a Columbo and psych Darcy into sneaking into the studio the night before a purported deep sweep of the crime scene to ensure she had removed all the beads.
I also thought of Columbo during a quicker, more vexing moment that speaks to a potential long-term issue with how Elsbeth is characterized. I remain a huge fan of Carrie Preston’s performance, and I largely find Elsbeth to be delightful in spite of her general too-much-ness. She is who she is, and that’s why she’s lovable. However, if you watch enough later episodes of Columbo, it is equal parts fascinating and frustrating to watch Peter Falk and the writers try to figure out how to depict the shambled detective in a way that feels true to his character without being too cartoonish or obnoxious. How many “Just one more things” can you do per episode before it feels like a parody? (As an example.)