Review: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power| Season 3, Episodes 5-6
Many things happen, some of them interesting
Boy, there’s a lot of torture on this show, huh? We’re covering two episodes this week instead of four (thank you, Gods of Amazon), but even in those two, we spend more time with Sauron making characters suffer for information than I would’ve expected. To be clear, I didn’t really have expectations re: torture going into this season, but we have absolutely surpassed whatever baseline assumptions I have for any piece of media, especially if we’re taking into consideration Sauron’s aggressive hiring policies. He’s not quite at Jack Bauer levels, but I feel like the two would have some things to talk about, should the multiverse ever collapse far enough for them to meet.
It’s not that I think Sauron needs to be nicer or anything foolish like that; it’s more that it demonstrates a lack of imagination on the part of the show’s writers that they only seem to have half a dozen tricks up their sleeve, and at this point, we’ve seen them all several times over. The two torture sequences (first Marnukh in “The Lady of Lorien,” then Celeborn in “From Valinor”) are compelling enough as standalone scenes, but like so much of the show, they reduce mythical figures and horrifying threats into just a bunch of guys doing things guys have been doing to each other since the beginning of time.
Really, it’s indicative of a larger issue I have, one that was apparent in the first four episodes but became frustratingly clear this week: while the show’s creative team understands dramatic moments, they lack the ability to craft a narrative where said moments build off one another in a satisfying fashion, instead simply presenting us with a series of plot beats and twists from other stories and hoping that will be enough. There’s nothing wrong with using tropes like torture or betrayal or reversals of fortune in a plot, but ideally they should connect in a way that makes them feel like more than just a collection of bits.